desuetude

Toomas Liiva 28.05.2001 16:19 (24 aastat tagasi)

Desuetude kohta leidub tõesti vähe materjaali. Paar rida võis leida Tanel Kerikmäe, LL.M., LL.Lic. ja Hannes Vallikivi kirjatööst "State Succession in the Light of Estonian. Treaties Concluded before World War II":<BR> <I>The right of states to terminate a treaty on the basis of a provision permitting termination "tacitly contained" therein is disputable. The International Law Commission has accepted the concept of desuetude: a tacit consent to terminate the treaty, if the consent has been clearly expressed in the behaviour of the states. Desuetude should not be applicable to open multilateral agreements. For example, the practice of the UN as a depositary concerning the treaties concluded during the last one hundred years considers all of them valid. A state wishing to withdraw from such a treaty can do it according to the provisions of this treaty. Closed multilateral treaties and trilateral or bilateral treaties are a different case. The cause for the conclusion of such treaties is the interest of the states in relation to other particular states. In such a case, the failure to implement the treaty proves...</I><BR> Peale selle võib desuetude kohta leida USA ülemkohtu praktikat, kui klikata <A HREF="http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/casesearch.pl?cirestriction=desuetude&court=us" TARGET="_blank">siia</A>.

ago 28.05.2001 20:57 (24 aastat tagasi)

Kontou, N. The Termination and Revision of Treaties in the Light of New Customary International Law, Clarendon Press Oxford, 1994, p 169 See oleks üheks parimaks olemasolevaks ja Eestis kättesaadav (Rahvusraamatukogus) olev monograafia, kus üsna pikalt analüüsitakse ka desuetude doktriini. ehk leiab midagi ka ILC materjalidest